Home - Knowledge - Details

1.4112 vs 1.4404 Stainless Steel: Wear Resistance or Corrosion Resistance

Two Metallurgical Families, Not Two Grades of One Steel

1.4112 and 1.4404 are frequently compared because both are stocked as bar, plate and wire, but they belong to different families. 1.4112, or X90CrMoV18, is a high-carbon martensitic stainless steel carrying roughly 0.9 % carbon, about 18 % chromium, around 1 % molybdenum and a small vanadium addition. It hardens to a working hardness in the high 50s HRC and is selected for wear resistance. 1.4404, or X2CrNiMo17-12-2, is the low-carbon, molybdenum-bearing austenitic grade known as Type 316L, with carbon capped at 0.030 % and 2.00 to 2.50 % molybdenum, selected for corrosion resistance and weldability.

Neither grade substitutes for the other. When a component fails early, the cause is usually not a bad heat but the wrong family having been specified for the service.

Designations and Equivalents

System 1.4112 1.4404
EN designation X90CrMoV18 (1.4112) X2CrNiMo17-12-2 (1.4404)
ASTM / AISI Martensitic 440B class, UNS S44003 Type 316L, UNS S31603
Standards EN 10088-3; ASTM A276 (bar) EN 10088-2 and 10088-3; ASTM A240, A276
Japan SUS440B (JIS G4303) SUS316L (JIS G4303, G4304, G4305)
China Closest national designation is the 9Cr18MoV type; equivalence is approximate 022Cr17Ni12Mo2 (GB/T 20878)

The Chinese designation for 316L is 022Cr17Ni12Mo2 under GB/T 20878. For the martensitic grade, the closest Chinese designation is the 9Cr18MoV type; because the two systems were written independently, the equivalence is approximate and the acceptance criteria should be taken from the drawing rather than from a trade name.

Chemical Composition in Practice

Element, % 1.4112 (X90CrMoV18) 1.4404 (316L, EN 10088-3)
C 0.85-0.95 0.030 max
Cr About 18 (nominally 17-19) 16.5-18.5
Ni Not specified (residual) 10.0-13.0
Mo About 1 (nominally 0.9-1.3) 2.00-2.50
V About 0.1 Not specified

Carbon is the controlling element in 1.4112. It forms hard chromium carbides that give the grade its wear resistance, and it is also the reason the grade is difficult to weld and to machine in the hardened state. In 1.4404 the carbon level is deliberately suppressed to 0.030 % or less so that chromium stays in solid solution and no carbide network forms at grain boundaries during welding.

Strength, Hardness and How Each Grade Is Specified

1.4112 is normally hardened from about 1010 to 1065 degrees C, oil quenched, and then tempered in the 150 to 300 degrees C range to reach the final hardness. Double tempering is recommended to reduce retained austenite. Because a 0.9 % carbon martensitic steel at 56 to 60 HRC is brittle in a tensile test, the grade is specified by hardness and by metallographic acceptance criteria rather than by a tensile strength value.

1.4404 works in the opposite way. It cannot be hardened by heat treatment and is supplied in the solution annealed condition with a minimum 0.2 % proof strength of 170 MPa, a minimum tensile strength of 485 MPa and a minimum elongation of 40 % under ASTM A240. Strength is raised only by cold work, and cold working reduces ductility and increases the risk of galling on sliding surfaces.

Corrosion Resistance: Where the Gap Opens

A pitting resistance equivalent number, calculated as chromium plus 3.3 times molybdenum plus 16 times nitrogen, puts 1.4404 at about 24 to 26 and 1.4112 at a nominal value near 21. The nominal comparison understates the real gap. In the martensitic grade most of the chromium is tied up in carbide and the matrix is depleted, the structure is not uniform, and there is no nickel to stabilise the passive film, so pitting and crevice attack start early in chloride service. The austenitic grade keeps its chromium in solution and develops a stable passive film that resists chlorides, mild acids and most food and pharmaceutical media.

Environment 1.4112 (X90CrMoV18) 1.4404 (316L)
Fresh water, mild atmospheres Acceptable Good
Chlorides, sea water splash Poor; pitting expected Good in splash zone, not for permanent immersion in hot sea water
Dilute acids and food media Limited by surface finish and hardness Good, widely used
Abrasion and edge retention Excellent at 56-60 HRC Poor; low hardness and strong galling tendency

Selection by Application

Application Correct choice Reason
Cutting blades, knives, scissors, shear blades 1.4112 Hardness and edge retention
Surgical cutting instruments 1.4112 Edge retention after repeated sterilisation
Pump and valve internals, process pipework 1.4404 Chloride and acid resistance, weldability
Tanks, heat exchangers, food contact surfaces 1.4404 Cleanable, non-galling, corrosion resistant
Wear plates and bearing components 1.4112 Wear resistance under load
Offshore, desalination and marine hardware Neither; use a duplex or super duplex grade Both grades are inadequate for permanent sea water exposure

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Which grade has better corrosion resistance, 1.4112 or 1.4404?
A: 1.4404 by a wide margin. Its austenitic matrix, molybdenum content and low carbon keep chromium in solution, while 1.4112 carries most of its chromium in carbide form and pits early in chloride service.

Q: Can 1.4404 be hardened to knife hardness?
A: No. It is austenitic and cannot be hardened by heat treatment. Cold rolling raises its strength moderately but never approaches the 56 to 60 HRC of hardened 1.4112.

Q: Is 1.4112 the same as Type 440C?
A: No. It belongs to the 440B class, with about 0.9 % carbon. Type 440C carries roughly 1.0 to 1.1 % carbon, giving higher hardness and lower toughness.

Q: Why is 1.4112 difficult to weld?
A: Its high carbon and martensitic structure produce a hard, crack-prone heat-affected zone. Where a welded joint is unavoidable, preheat, controlled interpass temperature and immediate post-weld heat treatment are all required.

Q: Which grade is easier to machine?
A: 1.4404 in the annealed condition machines cleanly, though it work hardens and tends to gall. 1.4112 is machined either in the soft annealed state or after hardening and tempering, when it must be ground rather than turned.

Q: Is there a single grade that covers both duties?
A: Not within these two families. Where wear and chloride corrosion occur together, specify a hardened martensitic part for the wear surface and an austenitic or duplex part for the wetted structure, or move to a duplex grade with a surface hardening treatment.

Send Inquiry

You Might Also Like