Duplex and Austenitic Stainless Steel: Pickling, Passivation and Welding Practice
Leave a message
Why Stainless Steel Stays Stainless
Stainless steel is not corrosion-free by nature; it is protected by a thin, self-repairing chromium oxide film that forms spontaneously on a clean surface in the presence of oxygen. The film is only a few nanometres thick, yet it is the reason a stainless component can survive decades in a wet industrial environment. Two conditions must be met for the film to form and remain intact: the alloy must contain sufficient chromium, and the surface must be free of scale, embedded iron, heat tint and other contamination.
Austenitic grades such as Alloy 304 and Alloy 316 contain 16 - 18% chromium, which is normally enough to build the passive film. Duplex grades carry considerably more chromium, typically 19% and up to about 32% in super-duplex compositions, so their passive film is more robust and recovers faster after damage. When chromium is consumed by carbide precipitation or obscured by oxide scale, local depletion occurs, and the exposed area becomes an initiation point for pitting and crevice attack.
Chromium Level, Microstructure and Corrosion Behaviour
| Family | Typical chromium | Microstructure | Engineering note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Austenitic (Alloy 304, 316L) | 16 - 18% | fully austenitic, non-magnetic | broad availability and good formability; limited chloride stress corrosion resistance |
| Lean duplex (2304) | about 23% | austenite plus ferrite | cost-effective replacement for Alloy 316L in chloride service |
| Standard duplex (2205 / UNS S32205) | 22 - 23% | roughly 50% ferrite | high yield strength, PREN 33 - 34, heat exchangers and pressure vessels |
| Super-duplex (2507 / UNS S32750) | 24 - 26% | roughly 50% ferrite with high Mo and N | PREN above 40, seawater and desalination service |
Looking at typical applications: 2205 is widely used for heat exchangers and pressure vessels, while 2507 is the usual choice for pressure vessels, desalination plants and seawater systems where chloride levels make Alloy 316L impractical. In both cases the ferrite phase carries most of the strength, and the austenite phase preserves toughness and weldability.
Pickling: Removing Scale and Depleted Surface Layers
Pickling is the chemical removal of oxide scale and chromium-depleted metal from the surface. Scale forms whenever stainless steel is exposed to elevated temperature, most commonly during welding, hot forming or heat treatment. Below the scale there is always a shallow layer in which chromium has been drawn out of solution, and this layer will corrode even though the base metal is perfectly sound.
Mechanical methods such as grinding and blasting can remove scale, but they tend to smear metal, embed iron particles and leave a mechanically disturbed surface that passivates poorly. Chemical pickling avoids those defects. Acid mixtures based on nitric acid (HNO₃) with hydrofluoric acid (HF) additions dissolve scale effectively; a typical immersion bath operates in the range of 20 - 25% nitric acid with 2 - 4% hydrofluoric acid at 20 - 60 °C, depending on the grade and the scale thickness. The hydrofluoric acid attacks the chromium-depleted metal, while the nitric acid stabilises the freshly exposed surface and assists passivation. Process time, temperature and acid concentration are matched to the alloy, because duplex grades with high molybdenum and nitrogen content pickle more slowly than standard austenitic grades.
After pickling, the surface must be rinsed thoroughly. Residual acid or fluoride left in crevices and weld toes will cause localised attack, so a final rinse with clean water, ideally followed by a check for embedded iron, is part of the procedure.
Passivation and Testing
Passivation is a chemical treatment, normally in nitric acid solution, that removes free iron and other metallic contamination from the surface and allows the chromium oxide film to re-form uniformly. It does not remove heavy scale.
Sequence: scale removal comes first, passivation second. Passivating a scaled surface leaves the scale in place and wastes the treatment.
Applicable standards: ASTM A380 covers cleaning and descaling practice, and ASTM A967 covers chemical passivation treatments and their acceptance criteria.
Verification: a water break test, ferroxyl test or copper sulphate test confirms that embedded iron has been removed and the passive film is continuous.
Mechanical finishing such as brushing or polishing may be applied after pickling for appearance, provided iron-free tools are used.
Welding Duplex and Austenitic Stainless Steel
Duplex grades are welded with the same family of arc processes used for austenitic stainless steel, but with tighter control of heat input and interpass temperature because the ferrite-austenite balance must be preserved in the weld metal and heat-affected zone. The qualified processes include shielded metal arc welding (SMAW), flux-cored arc welding (FCAW), gas metal arc welding (GMAW, including MIG), gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW, including TIG), submerged arc welding (SAW), plasma arc welding (PAW), resistance welding, laser welding and high-frequency welding.
Filler metal: duplex grades are generally welded with a slightly over-alloyed nickel-rich filler, such as ER2209 for 2205 and ER2594 for 2507, so that the weld metal retains adequate austenite and corrosion resistance after cooling.
Heat input: controlled within roughly 0.5 - 2.5 kJ/mm. Excessive heat input promotes coarse ferrite and reduces toughness; too little heat produces excessive ferrite and lowers corrosion resistance.
Interpass temperature: normally kept below about 150 °C to limit nitride precipitation and preserve the phase balance.
Shielding and purge: oxygen must be excluded from the root, since heat tint reduces corrosion resistance and requires pickling afterwards.
Post-weld treatment: welds should be pickled and passivated, and duplex welds in critical service are validated by corrosion testing to ASTM A923.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the difference between pickling and passivation?
Pickling removes oxide scale and chromium-depleted metal with strong acid mixtures, while passivation removes free iron contamination and rebuilds the chromium oxide film, usually in nitric acid solution.
Q: Does duplex stainless steel need passivation after welding?
Yes. Welding destroys the passive film and leaves heat tint; pickling followed by passivation restores corrosion resistance equal to the parent metal.
Q: Why does duplex stainless steel pickle more slowly than austenitic steel?
The higher chromium, molybdenum and nitrogen content makes the oxide scale more resistant to acid attack, so longer times or stronger baths are required.
Q: Which filler metal is used for welding 2205?
A nickel-rich duplex filler such as ER2209 is standard, giving a weld metal with balanced austenite and ferrite and corrosion resistance matching the base metal.
Q: What interpass temperature should be used for duplex welding?
Below about 150 °C, with heat input held within roughly 0.5 - 2.5 kJ/mm to preserve the ferrite-austenite balance.
Q: Can 2205 replace Alloy 316L in pressure vessels?
Often yes, because its yield strength is roughly double, but the design code, temperature limits and welding qualification must be reviewed for each application.







